Minotaur Capital featured in the Australian Financial Review's coverage of Firmus Technologies' troubled $44 billion float. Had it proceeded at the original $11-a-share offer, it would have been the biggest ASX listing since Telstra in 1997. Instead, lukewarm demand pushed bankers to consider cutting the offer price or pulling the deal altogether.
Our portfolio manager Armina Rosenberg explained why we see the artificial intelligence infrastructure play as too risky, even at a lower offer price, given much of its revenue forecast is based on significant debts. She also noted that recent investors could exit quickly:
"Even at $8.25, new investors would be paying close to twice what Nvidia, Blackstone and Coatue paid in August, and those holders still aren't escrowed, I think more than half the register can sell on day one."
Our position is unchanged. As Armina put it, "The gap has narrowed, but it hasn't closed," so we will wait and see how the first sites deliver before revisiting our view.
The article highlights wider investor scepticism, including large US institutions pulling back their orders, a valuation that has risen eight-fold this year, and concerns that 97 per cent of Firmus' promised data centre capacity hasn't been built. Plato Investment Management said it had identified 30 red flags.
For us, the episode reinforces a simple principle: valuation discipline matters, even amid surging AI enthusiasm.
To read the article, click the link below.